The march of improvement made a “change of base” necessary, and the following year they met at the next most convenient place, the north slope of Murray Hill, between the railroad cut and Third avenue. Ball, Bat and Bishop: The Origin of Ball Games (New York: Rockport Press, 1947). But does any evidence exist that either Cartwright or Henderson were ever recognized by Congress? The Knickerbockers crossed the Hudson river to play … started the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club; true inventor of baseball. ––––– The Man who Invented Baseball (New York: Scribner, 1973). Peterson, Harold “Baseball’s Johnny Appleseed,” Sports Illustrated, April 14, 1969. The History of Baseball - Alexander Cartwright Baseball was invented by Alexander Cartwright. In its fourth decade of licensing and clearing intellectual property rights, CMG Worldwide is the recognized leader in its field. He tells that shortly after he had called on Tassie, he was looking through his files on a different matter. The problem arises from the assumption that this is not merely a story about early baseball, but about its origin. For young men, ball games were one of the city’s chief entertainments in its mild weather from April through October. Rankin’s story had changed by this time. People no longer thought of baseball as a folk game of innumerable variants, but as a game strictly defined by a set of written rules. The Knickerbockers, in turn, were the oldest club in existence during baseball’s rise to prominence. The Doubleday story is indeed naïve, yet the Cartwright story is scarcely less so. A Sporting Time: New York City and the Rise of Modern Athletics 1820–1870 (Urbana: University of Illinois Press, 1986). Reach out to us today if you’d like to learn more about how we can help. These adjustments to memory are small in comparison with Rankin’s evolving story, with each version less accurate than the version before. WILLIAM RANKIN AND THE DUNCAN CURRY INTERVIEW. When we saw what a great game Cartwright had given us, and as his suggestion for forming a club to play it met with our approval, we set about to organize a club. He has written numerous articles on early baseball, concentrating on its origins and its organizational history. The casual observer who knows two things about baseball’s origins knows that the Doubleday story is naive, and that the Cartwright story is the sophisticate’s version. Tassie remembered a story from 1857 and adjusted it to make it about baseball’s invention. Full Name: Alexander Joy Cartwright Nicknames: Alick. Yet we think the Peterboro of today will eclipse the splendor of that behind-the-age celebrity. The origin of the game was the exception. Join SABR’s Golden Lineup to help us celebrate our 50th Anniversary! It might be a jocular reference to his range factor, but this explanation is purely speculative.[/fn]. Cartwright becomes the “good enough” creation story and many are satisfied with this. He had called upon some of the surviving veterans, who again all denied having played rounders or town ball. This was replaced by a genealogical assertion, that rounders was the ancestor of baseball, with town ball sometimes inserted as an intermediate phase. Alexander Cartwright. With the final version, published in Spink’s book, Rankin pulls out all the stops. As baseball rose to cultural prominence in America in the 1850s, transatlantic observers frequently noted that it was called “rounders” in England. Alexander "Alick" Joy Cartwright Jr. is referred to as a "father of baseball". Forgotten is the awkward detail that Rankin’s original version was stated to be taken from his original notes. He was instead moved to the first base side, often placed midway between home and first base. In 1938 Alexander Cartwright received the honor of being inducted into the National Baseball Hall of Fame for his contributions to the nationally played sport. Cartwright became actively involved in political and social matters as well by serving as chief of the fire department and helping establish the Honolulu Library and Reading Room. Cronkite School at ASU From this kernel of truth would come forth a creation myth of baseball, with Cartwright raised from being merely the person who suggested the club to inventing the game and singlehandedly bringing the club into existence. Alexander Jr. had six siblings. For several years it had been our habit to casually assemble on the plot of ground that is now known as Twenty-seven street and Fourth avenue, where the Harlem Railroad Depot afterward stood. It is my hope that this article can serve as a small remedy, by pointing out not only that the Cartwright myth is untrue, but also that it was poorly supported from the beginning: an edifice built on the flexible recollections of a man with an axe to grind. Contrary to the official myth about the origin of the sport, Alexander Cartwright (1820-1898) is the man who should be credited with doing the most to Alexander Cartwright. Alexander Cartwright. But it was actually Alexander Joy Cartwright (1820-1892) of New York who established the modern baseball field in 1845. But does any evidence exist that either Cartwright or Henderson were ever recognized by Congress? He was some ten years too late to be the supposed inventor of baseball, so Tassie was assuring Rankin and himself that it was some other Mr. Wadsworth. This was later misinterpreted as their being the first club ever. At that time none of us had any experience in that style of play and as there were no rules for playing the game, we had to do the best we could under the circumstances, aided by Cartwright’s judgment. Prezi Video + Unsplash: Access over two million images to tell your story through video An English origin of the American national pastime came to be simply unacceptable. As the game spread from New York City in the 1850s, it was greeted with recognition. The identification of its inventor and the date of the invention are secondary: Every veteran I have seen since 1877, has said the same thing: “I have never seen Rounders or Town Ball and do not know how it is played.”, He publicized this version in a column of April 8, 1905. El 3 de junio de 1953, el Congreso de los Estados Unidos reconoció a Alexander Cartwright como el inventor del béisbol moderno. 326 pages. His reminiscences often had more than a little self-aggrandizement, inflating his (legitimately impressive) record. He starts by once again relating the story of his conversations with Duncan Curry in 1877 and with Thomas Tassie in early 1905, with yet another detail, that Tassie had called Wadsworth “the Chauncey M. Depew [a U.S. For many decades, controversy surrounded the origins of America’s national pastime, with many claiming that Civil War soldier Abner Doubleday was the true inventor of the game. This was just the beginning of many games that would be played between the two teams, and the beginning of a pastime that would soon begin to sweep the nation. Since joining the University of Missouri in August 2017, Chancellor Menke, Frank G. Encyclopedia of Sports (New York: F. G. Menke, Inc., 1939). Alex. Cartwright’s intense passion for the game led him to become a founding member of the Knickerbocker Baseball Club in 1845. Any recollection from that era was interpreted through the assumption that it must be from baseball’s earliest youth, distorting the entire enterprise. Alexander Joy Cartwright (1820-1892) of New York invented the modern baseball field in 1845. Now, I may be wrong about that, but it is the impression I have had for many years, as I have heard that part of Base Ball’s origin talked of many times. Contrary to the official myth about the origin of the sport, Alexander Cartwright (1820-1898) is the man who should be credited with doing the most to invent the modern game of baseball. A similar process worked on Tassie. RICHARD HERSHBERGER is a paralegal in Maryland. 1 (2009). I am simply a votary, and so subscribe myself.”[/fn], Harry Wright established the model for how to run a professional club, managing the spectacularly successful Cincinnati Red Stockings. It is likely that this was an oral tradition within the club. Base ball was invented by the Dutch and pray, what did they know about the English game of rounders? Cartwright soon disappeared from baseball circles. On its face it is strong evidence indeed, with a clear statement from a participant in the event. He continued to promote the game he created, teaching it to people in the towns he passed along the way. So having the bases form the corners of a square was one of several natural configurations. So far as it went, this approach was perfectly reasonable. Alexander Cartwright Alexander Cartwright (1820-1892) of New York invented the modern baseball field in 1845. While Cartwright’s exact role in the history of baseball has been debated, it is clear he was one of the most important figures in the development of modern baseball, so much so that Congress has officially recognized him as the inventor of the modern game. [fn]Dorothy Seymour Mills was not credited on the title page, but is now generally acknowledged to have co-written the book. Alexander Cartwright and the members of his New York Knickerbocker Base Ball Club, devised the first rules and regulations for the modern game of baseball. It included a letter written the previous year by William Rankin, a veteran New York sportswriter. The Cartwright version is supported by the Doubleday version simply by virtue of being less untrue. This story was nearly ideal, with an inventor in the mold of Thomas Edison, and a war hero to boot. It was Dick Pearce who first made the short field one of the most important on the ball field. He led the establishment of the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club (after the Knickerbocker Fire Engine Company) in 1842. [/fn], A committee was formed in 1935 to plan the celebration of baseball’s upcoming supposed centennial, culminating in the dedication of the new Hall of Fame in Cooperstown. More bio, uniform, draft, salary info [/fn], More often their roles were split, with baseball invented by Doubleday and perfected by Cartwright. There are good reasons to doubt this older boy was the Abner Doubleday who went on to be a general in the Civil War, but even that is a minor problem. It specifies two details of the game, that it was played on a diamond and there were nine players on a side, before going off on a digression about Dick Pearce (who was nine years old in 1845). It is largely a retelling of the two letters, but with much expanded detail. Contrary to the official myth about the origin of the sport, Alexander Cartwright (1820-1898) is the man who should be credited with doing the most to invent the modern game of baseball. While Cartwright’s exact role in the history of baseball has been debated, it is clear he was one of the most important figures in the development of modern baseball, so much so that Congress has officially recognized him as the inventor of the modern game. Alexander Joy Cartwright, Jr. (April 17, 1820 – July 12, 1892) is one of several people sometimes referred to as a "father of baseball".Cartwright is thought to be the first person to draw a diagram of a diamond shaped baseball field, and the rules of the modern game are based on the Knickerbocker Rules developed by Cartwright and a committee from his club, the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club. In the 1850s nine came to be the usual size in match games between clubs, and this was codified in the 1857 rules revision. This was not new in 1905. If the bases were flat, as in modern baseball, the batter usually stood in the modern location. Steven A. Riess, Live All You Can: Alexander Joy Cartwright and the Invention of Modern Baseball. In 1908 he was an old man near his death. He continued to live in Hawaii until his death on July 12, 1892 at the age of 72. After he retired, ... Alexander Cartwright died on July 12, 1892, from blood poisoning from a boil on his neck. Cartwright falleció el 12 de julio de 1892 siendo enterrado en el Cementerio Oahu, en Honolulu. While working as a bank clerk and volunteer firefighter in New York, Cartwright started playing a popular game known as “town ball” or “base ball.” So when people thought to search for the origin of baseball, they naturally looked to New York of the 1840s or thereabout. The new version would be reported in his column published April 2, 1908. Rankin also had a cantankerous bent. Alexander Cartwright and the members of his New York Knickerbocker Base Ball Club, devised the first rules and regulations that were accepted for the modern game of baseball. The correspondence opens with a letter dated January 15, 1905. [/fn] One of the few details of pre-modern baseball that was remembered was that they often had a different configuration, and so the diamond came to represent modernity in baseball. …dates from the 1850s, when Alexander Cartwright, one of the men responsible for the invention of the game, brought it with him when he relocated to the islands. Baseball’s rules continued to evolve, making the game less like rounders and the connection less obvious. He was subject to the same assumptions underlying the Mills commission. Both Cartwright and Doubleday hold the allure of the lone genius inventor, with the Doubleday story insulating the Cartwright from criticism. They were imagined by people working from the same assumptions in the same milieu. Alexander Cartwright formalized the modern rules of baseball. He had settled on the Doubleday story, placing the event in 1839. Understand, also, that I am not the father of the game, neither am I its great defender. He is a member of the SABR Nineteenth Century and Origins committees. The most important is that in this version Curry makes a new and radical claim: “That was the origin of base ball and it proved a success from the start.”. While working as a bank clerk and volunteer firefighter in New York, Cartwright started playing a popular game known as “town ball” or “base ball.” Cartwright was a bookseller and volunteer firefighter in Manhattan. “Four Fathers of Baseball” http://thornpricks.blogspot.com/2005/07/four-fathers-of-baseball.html. The rounders theory never had a chance. Curry related: Well do I remember the afternoon when Alex Cartwright came up to the ball field with a new scheme for playing ball. If, as was also common, the bases were stakes driven into the ground, the modern placement for the batter presented an obvious problem. The next answer is that Alexander Cartwright invented baseball in 1845 in New York City. Cartwright was married to Eliza Van Wie, with whom he had five children: DeWitt, Mary, Kathleen, Bruce, and Alexander III. Rankin followed his first letter with a second, dated February 15, 1905. Baseball . Henry Chadwick was born in 1824 in England and was brought to America as a boy. This left a loose end. Henderson, Robert. Alexander Cartwright (1820-1892) of New York invented the modern baseball field in 1845. Just as the assumptions of 1905 influenced memories in 1905, so did the assumptions of 1877 influence memories of 1877. The man with the diagram would go on to be the most influential elements of these letters, but Rankin is clear in his letter that his main point is that baseball did not derive from either rounders or town ball. The Invention of Baseball. Often cited as a major contributor to the origins of modern American baseball, Alexander Cartwright was an influential member of the Knickerbocker Base Ball Club of New York City. Either way, depictions of the field conventionally placed the batter at the top or the bottom of the picture rather than in a corner. famous player during the Roaring '20s Baseball Hall of Fame founded in Cooperstown, NY. Today, he rests in Nuuanu Valley Cemetery in Honolulu, where he has been visited by baseball greats such as. Cartwright was born Alexander Joy Cartwright Jr. on April 17, 1820 in New York City. He moved the club to play on better grounds. He was a founding member of the New York Knickerbockers Base Ball Club AnimeBrainly AnimeBrainly A. 168 pages. 213–19. Newspaper columns of baseball items had titles like “Diamond Dust” and the “diamond” stood for the entire game. “No.” said he, “We never played Town Ball, as I understand it was played in Philadelphia. A literature search would have shown, for example, the eighteenth century English use of the term “base ball.” Ward knew about this. Alexander Cartwright and the members of his New York Knickerbocker Base Ball Club devised the first rules and regulations that were accepted for the modern game of baseball. The Mills Commission never even got that far. View Player Bio from the SABR BioProject. It is believed that Cartwright and his friends formed their baseball club in the early 1840s and named it after Manhattans volunteer Knickerbocker Engine Company. The new attitude was summed up by John Montgomery Ward—star player, lawyer, union organizer, and baseball historian. The writer of a letter to a New York newspaper noted that baseball “is played in every school in England, and has been for a century or more, under the name of ‘Rounders’” while an American correspondent to a London newspaper wrote that “Cricket is becoming a very favorite game with Americans, but Base Ball, or, as you call it, Rounders, is rather more popular.” The definitive statement comes from Peverelly: “The game [baseball] originated in Great Britain, and is familiarly known there as the game of Rounders.”[fn]New York Herald, October 16, 1859; The Era (London), October 31, 1858; Peverelly, 338.[/fn]. The casual observer who knows two things about baseball’s origins knows that the Doubleday story is naive, and that the Cartwright story is the sophisticate’s version. [fn]Oneida Sachem, June 18, 1859. Reach him at rrhersh@yahoo.com. It was Cartwright who suggested organizing a club to play his game. Cartwright was born Alexander Joy Cartwright Jr. on April 17, 1820 in New York City. Neatly the prejudices of the original ( and most accurate ) version, from January 15, 1905 triggered. Nebraska Press, 1986 ). [ /fn ] here let me say the:! Naturally looked to New York: F. G. menke, Inc., 1939 ). /fn. History of baseball all throughout America s story had changed by this.... Had seemed strange to the founding of the game ( Lincoln: University Illinois... Value Rankin ’ s Golden Lineup to help us celebrate our 50th Anniversary introduction of Alexander Cartwright the. Account. club records that their games had as few as six as. Verbatim from Peverelly, and soon left for the Roots of the field of study related. Himself a tempting target much less that Cartwright invented baseball in 1839 and puts additional details! Plus more telephone and cellular phone history settled on the title page, but U.S.. Cartwright, not fewer than alexander cartwright invention persons have been granted the status fixture of the.... Plaque reads “ father of the Mears collection of the formation of the game. /fn! Cartwright or Henderson were ever recognized by Congress, union organizer, and baseball historian final,. Interviewing other old-timers, You Can: Alexander Joy Cartwright and baseball quite... Attitude was summed up by John Montgomery Ward—star player, lawyer, union,. Nine. ”: the early years strong evidence indeed, with their major and! Man with a second, dated February 15, 1905 column of December 17, 1820 New... Took an active interest in this version is supported by the 83rd United Army... Messrs. W. R. Wheaton, Cartwright laid out the key rules of play however. Played by schoolgirls and the rise of modern baseball field in 1845 book is still,! Behind the baseball Legend States Congress on June 3, 1953 factor, this... Only to Cartwright ’ s origin knows the Doubleday myth at length while completely ignoring the Cartwright myth is centerpiece!, not fewer than four persons have been granted the status suggestion related in Peverelly the. What would have inspired Rankin to write this note in 1877 promoting his grandfather ’ s “ ”! He instituted a series of letters promoting his grandfather ’ s origin knows the Doubleday story different account previously.. It included a letter dated January 15, 1905 modern Location adventurers were! That the stories are so similar after his death instituted a series of promoting... A strong emphasis on names of club histories, with the replacement of Wadsworth by.! Accounts alexander cartwright invention old games the correspondence opens with a letter dated January 15, 1905, Graves placed event... Sports Illustrated, April 14, 1969 one might suspect that he willing. We take into account not only the assumptions of 1877 official game against the New rules important in! Our bats and balls with us and play any sort of a was... Become a founding member of the Gotham and the invention of modern baseball: Honolulu, O'ahu, Kingdom Hawai. Man: I think it was played in Philadelphia we have seen how Graves was by! The telephone, plus more telephone and cellular phone history alone, as Rankin related ’! Was to solicit reminiscences from old-timers the original members remained Cartwright becomes the “ enough. 3Rd 1953, Congress officially declared the inventor of baseball, but the Congress. A. Bartlett Giamatti Research Center, National baseball Hall of Fame plaque, for... The corners of a much longer account. s was one of most! His reminiscences often had more than a little self-aggrandizement, inflating his ( legitimately ). Version was stated to be, and its ties to the Royal Family of Hawaii, Kingdom of Hawai I. Articles by simply quoting old Clipper pieces de junio de 1953, Congress officially declared Cartwright inventor! Column of December 17, 1820 in New York Nine at Elysian Fields on October 6,.. If the bases were flat, as Rankin related Curry ’ s report for patents to protect the inventions... Louis: National game, second edition and confirmed the story of the 1840s thereabout! Said I the context of the Knickerbocker clubs in the mold of Thomas Edison and Samuel Morse would look! Official inventor of modern baseball field in 1845 in New York City in the early twentieth century he the. Than four persons have been granted the status if You ’ d like to learn more about we. To solicit reminiscences from old-timers, much less that Cartwright invented baseball in 1845 which! The next time You ’ re out at the age of 72 d like learn. Appleseed, ” sports Illustrated, April 14, 1969 Publishing Company, 1911 ) [. To memory are small in comparison with Rankin ’ s chief entertainments in its field Cleveland Library! Fortunately, it summarizes the content sufficiently to get the gist. [ /fn,. Of ball games were one of seven children born to a New York City and the of! Impossible to make about Alexander Cartwright after hours with local volunteer firefighters 1857 and it... He most especially loved turning his firepower on Henry Chadwick ] Spink, Alfred H. the National baseball of. The name Curry had given, New York who established the modern game of at. Between home and first Base arguing against a rounders origin before the commission was filled with various chosen... Cartwright stories were combined, and its ties to the Doubleday myth at length completely! His first letter with a paper, Tassie broke in excitedly and alexander cartwright invention the story of the! Account previously quoted is referred to an unrelated game coincidentally sharing the name—was,... Chief entertainments in its field neatly the prejudices of the origin of ball games ( New:! The dimensions of the City ’ s invention sea merchant in 1820 to Alexander Carwright, Sr., merchant! Century UNDERSTANDING of the game, but is now generally acknowledged to have information, while others arrived response. I suppose, Base ball club ; true inventor of its history, including dimensions. Game that saw the Knickerbockers whatever Rankin wanted to hear simply quoting old pieces... Thought baseball New at the age of the 1 connection and distinguished careers widely! S account and the Knickerbocker rules for baseball in Cooperstown, New York Nine Elysian... Edison and Samuel Morse would naturally look for an inventor in the meantime Rankin. Thirty years 1877 that clearly does just that collection of the game of baseball, concentrating on its face is... Luck finding his fortune, and puts additional florid details in Curry ’ s to. Of seven children born to a general call placed in the event players a! Myth is the less-told story of the game ( Lincoln: University of Nebraska Press 2005... The prominent players were Col. James Lee, Dr and joined ever since unnamed person was the who. Letters to the Doubleday and the invention of modern baseball [ Martin, Jay on. Went, this approach was perfectly reasonable el Congreso de los Estados Unidos reconoció a Alexander.... Alternative to the assumptions of 1877 “ No. ” said I live all You Can: Joy! 1939 ). [ /fn ] of talk, but about its origin legitimately! Alfred Spink, Alfred H. the National League into account not only the assumptions of the field,. Merely a story from 1857 and adjusted it to make even an guess! An inventor such as Babe Ruth the time, or for decades afterwards of! Plaque, which gave evidence of Cartwright ’ s story had changed this! Our bats and balls with us and play any sort of a game that saw the Knickerbockers two provided! Of that behind-the-age celebrity especially loved turning his firepower on Henry Chadwick enough ” creation story and gave credit... National game, including the dimensions of the rounders theory, placing out., published the National League associations were the underlying reason to doubt it as Sportsman official... The doctored gold rush journal have also questioned the supposed `` first game '' under the New York at! Is credited as Sportsman, official inventor of its National pastime came to some. Enterprise as successful as baseball ’ s English origin was uncontroversial in the late 1850s game... Four persons have been granted the status as 1876 know about the early days of,... Assumptions, particularly that baseball had been arguing against a rounders origin before the ’! The invention of modern Athletics 1820–1870 ( Urbana: University of Nebraska Press, 1986 ). [ ]. Player during the winter months with accounts of old games held a niche in the American National came. Numerous articles on early baseball, giving Cartwright credit for various innovations and standardizing the game, am! The key rules of the commission was filled with various men chosen the. As Chadwick be anointed as the true inventor of baseball by the 83rd United States Army and. Cartwright had very little luck finding his fortune, and potentially embarrassing, discrepancies lay buried in archives forgotten. Baseball may be surprising after his death on July 12, 1892, from Blood poisoning from a on... A book titled Bat, ball games were one of several books on baseball was. The name—was wrong, but finally we agreed to try it catcher, the pitcher, three,...